I also watched Jerry Seinfeld's Jerry Before Seinfeld (full feature on Netflix) in which he reminisces about his early days and tells the same jokes from his first stand up show. You know it's comedy gold when it's still funny so many years later.
"I'm left-handed. Left-handed people do not like that the word 'left' is so often associated with negative things: Two left feet, left-handed compliments, 'What are we having for dinner?' 'Leftovers'. You go to a party, there's nobody there. 'Where'd they go?' 'They left.'"
That took me down a comedy slide and I've been enjoying many comedy shows on Netflix. It's the mixture of delivery, story-telling, pop culture references, hyperbole, crazy antics, weird sounds, facial expressions, off-beat wording, and the "that's so true"mixed with "I can't believe they just said that" aspect of whatever it is they're saying.
Just this week I secured last minute tickets (20 minutes before showtime) to see John Mulaney: Kid Gorgeous at The Paramount in Seattle. So good! He has fairly clean content - lots of stories from his childhood and his Catholic-lawyer parents with a fair amount of self-depreciating humor mixed in. When he loops back to an earlier joke in his set, making you laugh even harder, you know he's good :) You can find two of his shows on Netflix The Comeback Kid and New in Town.
"I was once on the telephone with Blockbuster Video...which is a very old-fashioned sentence."
Mike Birbiglia - this guy is great and my current favorite. Admittingly some off-color humor but he does a really good job of mixing in jokes while he's taking you on one big themed conversation, weaving in sidebar stories and even some sentimental insights effortlessly. He has three different shows currently on Netflix. I started with My Girlfriend's Boyfriend but also really like his Thank God for Jokes.
"I know. I'm in the future also."
"So what late people don't understand about us on-time people is that we hate you. And the reason why we hate you is it's so easy to be on time. You just have to be early. And early lasts for hours."
Dmitri Martin: Live (At the Time) - Some cursing but overall a very very dry sense of humor. Mostly short disconnected bits that are centered on puns and word play :) He does some drawings and clever observational commentary using a guitar & harmonica too.
"I have an L-shaped sofa - lower case."
"Food is tricky, like milk: It starts out good, then it becomes bad, then it becomes disgusting, then it becomes dangerous, then it becomes cheese. Way to turn it around, milk!"
Brian Regan - A classic full-nonsense comedian. He's known for his clean content and exaggerated, sarcastic humor. He has several great routines, but the one I could watch over and over again in Brian Regan: StandingUp because anticipating the punch line/quoting along with him is twice as good. Mr. Fleece can recite "Flight Delayed" and "Baby Books" almost word for word.
"So when you do board, the first class people, they're sitting there. A lot of them are working as you're boarding. They have computers out and calculators. They're looking up at you like, 'Hey, we're making money right now! Right now we're making money.'"
-SJW